Tragedy: Cop Mistakenly Kills Family Dog

Published May 31, 2012

Flickr User outlier*

A Border Collie mixed breed dog was mistakenly shot and killed by a Fort Worth police officer. Editor's Note: This is NOT a photo of Lillie.

Mistaking a black and white Border collie mix breed dog named Lillie for a pit bull and feeling threatened by an oncoming canine attack, a Fort Worth, Texas police officer responding to a call to assist in an investigation of a copper theft shot and killed Lillie. The tragedy occurred right before the disbelieving eyes of Lillie’s owners, Cindy and Mark Boling.

According to a recent article on CW33.com, the couple had just returned home from shopping and was unloading their truck. In their driveway with them were their family dogs, Lillie and Gracie. As they were standing in the driveway, they noticed a police officer walking toward them. Being friendly and trusting dogs, both of them started heading their way to greet the officer.

Mark called out the officer, to let him know that the dogs didn’t bite and were friendly, and he was on his way to get them to put them in the yard. He asked him not to hurt the dogs. Mark was able to catch up with Gracie and grab her collar, however Lillie ran up to the porch where the officer was standing.

In a matter of seconds, before Mark had time to intervene, the police officer drew his pistol and shot Lillie in the back. The critically injured dog ran into the back yard where, sadly, she died within minutes of being shot.

You may be asking what led up to this lamentable event occurring? This tragedy never should have taken place at all.

Due to a horrendous mistake, the police officer arrived at the wrong house. He was given the address 4917 Norma Street, to help in the investigation of the copper theft report. However, in error, he went to the Boling's house instead. Their house number is 4717 which is two blocks away from the house to which he was sent.

A neighbor who overheard the officer talking to another policeman who was at the scene allegedly said he admitted that he was at the wrong house and, fearing that he was about to be attacked by a pit bull, he shot the dog.

No apology was made to the Bolings, who are devastated by their loss. Mark said, "My main concern is if he's going to shoot an animal like that how he is going to react then in a real situation with a weapon.” His wife, Cindy added, "We did everything in the world always to protect our girls. We never accounted for a man walking up our driveway with a gun and killing out little girl, our little Lillie.”

An officer with the Fort Worth Police Department, Daniel Segura’s side of the story, makes matters even more disturbing. His report states that the police officer investigating the copper theft report was on the 4900 Block on Norma, searching for suspects. Seeing Boling, he waited in the driveway, but two dogs suddenly began charging at him, barking aggressively. Although the officer asked the man several times to call off his dogs, (pleading with him to do so), the owner appeared not to be complying. As a result, he had no choice but to fire his “duty weapon”, striking the dog closest to him.

What I can’t get my head wrapped around is how it is possible for anyone to mistake a Border Collie mix with a pit bull, and why this officer just fired at a dog who was only running toward him to greet him.  Why was no apology offered to the Bolings?

This writer feels strongly that in order to prevent a similar tragedy from ever happening again, there is an urgent need for specialized training in handling canines for law enforcement personnel nationwide. What do you think? Share with a comment.

Author's profile photo
Jo Singer

Shortly after retiring as a social worker and psychotherapist, I discovered my "writer's voice"…

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (194)

Charles Pappa (Unverified)
1/2 the fault goes to the owners for not keeping the dogs leashed.
Anonymous (Unverified)
Police shot whoever or whatever they want and it's ok because they are in fear for their lives. Get used to it.
Anonymous (Unverified)
There are way too many cops these days with an arrogant attitude. They are meant to be servants of the public. Their character should not be capable of judging or ridiculing a person's love for their pet. In some cases, a person, for whatever reason, cannot have children. This cop's lack of compassion and understanding disqualify him (or her) from public service. Until our society starts to DEMAND quality from those we place in positions of power, we will continue to experience abuse............ "most of you clowns bashing the cops have never faced a moment of danger in your life. You have never had to make an important, life altering split-second decision before, and you don't have a clue as to the burden you carry when you wear a badge. Grow up. Dogs are great companions, but they are not "children". If you equate the two, you obviously don't have children of your own, and your grip on reality is questionable. No cop "wants" to have to shoot anyone or anyones pet. It is a cops worst nightmare to have to discharge a firearm at a person. If you've ever been attacked by a pitbull, and many have, including me, you have only a couple of seconds to decide whether you will become a Scooby snack or defend yourself. Control your animals. Don't put officers in that position. It's ironic how every animal owner thinks their little boo-boo is the most friendly dog around until it has their jaws wrapped around someone's leg. A little like how every parent of a thug thinks their criminal kid is a "good boy". Also, notice how the picture in this story is NOT of Lillie. Lillie very well might appear to be a pitbull."
Kimberly (Unverified)
This post is right on point! NOBODY who hasn't put their life on the line in dangerous situations can judge police officers. Dogs are also not "children." A dead dog is not something a police officer wants, but it is a much smaller price to pay than a trip to the hospital for dog bites or a trip to the morgue. This poster is also right about the picture not being of Lilly. I'm sure the dog was aggressive at the police officer. Some people should stick to their arm chairs, sofas and TV's and not judge the police.
Anonymous (Unverified)
what gets me the most is the cop lied through his teeth so he could justify the shooting. people cops are trained to lie both in reporting and interegation. if that had been my dog they would have had pry me off that guy.
Kimberly (Unverified)
How do you know? Were you there? First of all, it's "interrogation." Second, if you would have attacked that cop, you likely would have been shot too, that's how smart you are.
tasted-not-bit
There are at least 3 issues for further consideration. 1.) Postmen and women encounter similar situations with both strange and familiar dogs on a daily basis. How do they deal with the problem? 2.) Showing fear by exuding adrenaline in sweating, as anyone entering a risky situation is bound to have for a response, is an invitation for possible change in defensive attitude with most dogs. 3.) Prolonged staring eye encounter will frequently lead to aggressive response. Glance at, mostly look elsewhere may maintain status quo, or even calm the situation. What works me, Speak firmly, with commanding voice, then softly offer back of wrist for a sniff only if a slowing of the initial charge is noted, not everyone can do this successfully.