Proposed Pet Sale Ban Sweeps Nation

Published July 14, 2010
Some grin at the cute puppies in the pet store window, while others grimace at their small wire cages. But now, pet stores in San Francisco must fight to continue selling these adorable critters after a proposed ban on pet sales. Philip Gerrie, secretary of the San Francisco Commission of Animal Control and Welfare, proposed the ban to the seven-member commission. The ban specifically targets "companion pets", which include animals like dogs, cats, hamsters, birds, and others that frequently end up in shelters. Gerrie first suggested the ban in an effort to outlaw puppy and kitten mills - often cited as a culprit for pet overpopulation. However, the proposed ban transcended the issue of pet overpopulation, and quickly gained publicity as The San Francisco Chronicle's front page story. After the proposed ban was widely publicized, animal rescuers and pet store owners attended the commission's meeting on Thursday evening in masses. Bird rescuer Mira Tweti decried impulsive purchases from pet stores - made with little consideration of the time and care needed to raise a pet. Tweti claimed that such pets are dumped into animal shelters when they become a hassle for owners, and are often euthanized after the animals fail to secure new homes. And pet store owners expressed concern about the future of their business, with the proposed ban outlawing all pets, except fish. How many people would visit pet stores with such a limited selection? With so many perspectives to consider, the commission decided to table the discussion and the voting until at least another month. However, other cities have begun to heed the calls by the Humane Society of the Unites States and other proponents of the ban. Cities like Albuquerque, N.M., South Lake Tahoe, Calif., and West Hollywood, Calif. have already passed the ban with other cities in Florida, Missouri, New York, New Mexico, and elsewhere following close behind. So now is your chance to speak - where do you stand on the proposed ban on pet sales? Image source: flickr user Xhanatos

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (5)

Nicole (Unverified)

I don't think anyone should profit off the sale of companion animals, there is too much possibility for greed at the animal's expense, and also, millions of dogs and cats (especially cats) are killed every year due to shelter overpopulation and bad policy. I support this possibility 100%. it will force people who have been keeping animals as their private, abusable income source to find another way to survive. Breeding animals to sell as pets is not an honest, reputable income, it is abusive and unfair, and generates suffering and death. Do not breed or buy, while shelter pets die!

Rae (Unverified)

I agree that we need to control the population of domesticated animals, but with strict laws such as neutering/spaying being mandatory, elimination of the sale of animals, and various other restrictions, we have to be careful cause they can go extinct just like many other animals have because of human interference. I think it needs to start with much stricter regulation and enforcement of regulations against puppy mills, and with those regulations enforce on pet stores that they can only purchase from breeders who comply with the stricter government guidelines.

Alana
The proposed ban could be a big hindrance to pet stores. However, the ban is only a recommendation and not likely to be passed to become law. But, if the group succeeds, one of the most historic cities in the U.S. won't allow anybody to purchase a pet in the city limits. Here is the proof: City council group recommends San Francisco have total pet ban.
A (Unverified)
What a horrible proposal and a waste of our lawmakers supposedly valuable time. "Studies by UC Davis and the National Council on Pet Population Study and Policy have shown that only a small fraction of animals that wind up in shelters had been purchased at pet stores."
Emily (Unverified)
It is not just about that though. People are buying dogs and then months later they discover illness that is sometimes fatal. Many of the puppies in pet stores do not come from reputable breeders and are victims of puppy mills. It is also to prevent impulse buying. There will be no walking through a mall and happening upon a cute little puppy with no research in had and buying. Also why buy from a pet store when over 8 million dogs and cats are placed in a shelter each year and over half will be euthanized. Not because they are bad but simply because there is no room. Reptiles, dogs, and cats should not be sold in a pet store in my opinion.
JOANNE (Unverified)
I SUPPORT THE BAN 100%!!!
Anonymous
Me too!!!!!!