Op-Ed: Getting Rid of Cats Does Not Preserve Wildlife

Published January 31, 2013

Flickr/riebart

Cats are predators and innate hunters.

According to a survey conducted every five years by the American Veterinary Medical Association, pet ownership has been dwindling over the past five years in the United States. The most recent results of the survey were published in the  2012 U.S. Pet Ownership and Demographics Sourcebook. However, even though the pet population has been declining, today there continue to be approximately 74 million cats who continue to grace the hearts and homes of feline lovers.

Yet feline behavior continues to be highly misunderstood, resulting in some bad press for the species. In a recent study of cats by a jointly run University of Georgia and National Geographic study using webcams, they found that once cats “hit the fresh air ” these sweet and adorable felines turned into “killing machines”, and due to their hunting prowess, cats are responsible for the deaths of 4 million critters each year.

But there’s nothing personal about cat hunting and killing its prey. Cat guardians get such a kick out of playing with our kitties, tossing a toy mouse, or being awed while watching our cats leap into the air with the grace of a ballet dancer as they stretch out to catch the feathers on a wand.

Let’s face it: cats are predatory animals by nature. And even though we have domesticated these diminutive jungle cats, under that cute and cuddly fur coat is a skilled hunter’s instinctual hard-wiring. So while “Fluffy” or “Precious" might be sitting on your lap purring up a storm or gently tapping your nose with her paws, if she was permitted to roam outdoors without supervision, small reptiles, mammals and birds naturally become tantalizing mid-day snacks for our little “darlings."

But although there are untold numbers of cat lovers here in the United States, there are those who think that cats are a ghastly menace to wildlife.

According to a recent article on Mother Nature Network, “There’s no denying that nature can be cruel; beautiful and sublime, yet cruel." The article goes on to detail that in New Zealand, 9 species of native birds have gone extinct due to roaming felines, and they have also made a huge impact on 33 species of endangered birds.

As a result of this, Gareth Morgan, a philanthropic economist and businessman is dreaming of a New Zealand without cats. The opening statement made on Morgan’s website, Cat to go is, "That little ball of fluff you own is a natural born killer. Every year cats in New Zealand destroy our native wildlife. The fact is that cats have to go if we really care about our environment." He claims that without cats, New Zealand citizens will once again be able to hear a wide variety of songbird sounds, and rejoice in the beauty of these feathered beauties.

But Morgan is up against a tremendous number of New Zealand kitty aficionados, who are not at all happy with his desire to rid the country of cats. In fact, 71 percent of people polled on Morgan's website voted against his master plan.

Since cats easily learn to defeat a belled collar, folks who enjoy giving their cats access to the great outdoors can easily protect birds and other wildlife by building a secure kitty enclosure. This ensures that both cats and other species can live harmoniously together without upsetting Mother Nature’s precarious balance.

What do you think? Tell us in a comment.

Author's profile photo
Jo Singer

Shortly after retiring as a social worker and psychotherapist, I discovered my "writer's voice"…

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (9)

Susan Teays (Unverified)
Brava! Intelligent, informed comments about cats and the birds and the bees. A great site. Thank you.
Anonymous (Unverified)
People do wildlife of all sorts way more damage than cats. And if they would be responsible about their pets, there wouldn't be any ferals to worry about--they'd all have homes and not have more kittens.
Reno (Unverified)
Ridiculous. Obviously this guy doesn't realize that naimals that hunt prey are generally only successful at catching sick, injured, or old animals anyway. Those that would have died anyway. Good grief!
ICatnip Hill Gang (Unverified)
This dude's cheese has slid off his cracker. I kind of got the feeling that Gareth Morgan may be a cat hater. Yes, cats are natural born hunters. Yes, they do take the occasional bird. However, the stray cats here will sit and watch the bird feeders and they are not waiting to kill a bird. They are hunting squirrels, mice and the occasional rat or rabbit. The few birds that they do take are usually sick or injured. I hope Mr. Morgan never gets his way with this issue. If he thinks New Zealand has problems then maybe he should visit the USA and especially southern Florida. It is the native species and pets and people that are in danger and not from cats. Yikes!!
Reno (Unverified)
The cheese has slid off the cracker! I LOVE IT!!
Donna9331
REALLY? I MEAN...REALLY? Next thing you know they're going to want to eliminate predatory birds. How about sharks who kill other marine wildlife? And coyotes? (who by the way, do a pretty "good" job of taking down cats and other small mammals) Well, all I have to say is if New Zealand wants a cat free country, perhaps they should remember why cats came over on the Mayflower. To control rodents. I wish them a plague of widdle biddy mice...in every room of their home. It's called...the circle of life folks. I don't WANT species of birds to become extinct. I love birds...but that said, that's why God gave them wings. THAT said...if you own a cat, keep it indoors. It's where they belong anyway. If you disagree and allow your cat to roam, use a BREAKAWAY collar, with a bell (if the bird gets caught after hearing a belled cat, we're probably doing the species a favor by eliminating the DUMB ones...sorry...couldn't resist.)And if the cat comes home collar-less...put another one on him. Don't tell me it costs too much, you're the one that is putting your cat in danger by letting it outside. If you have outside/feral cats to help keep your barns and warehouses rodent free...GET THEM NEUTERED/SPAYED. As for the feral cats...they're killing for food and it's not their fault they're feral. I'm sticking with my circle of life theory. :::getting down off soapbox:::
R (Unverified)
I saw this the other day. This is the stupidest thing ever. It doesn't even deserve a reply. (Not YOU, them, the idiots behind this).