Maryland Court Rules Pit Bulls to be "Inherently Dangerous" Dogs

Published May 3, 2012

Flickr User pwcorgigirl

Are pit bulls dangerous dogs? A new ruling by a Maryland court says they are.

Breedism has reared its ugly head again in a recent decision made by the highest court in the state of Maryland last week. According to the new ruling reported by MSNBC, the Maryland court found that pit bulls are an "inherently dangerous" dog breed. The decision made by the Maryland Court of Appeals was reached after a series of pit bull related incidents and even deaths over the past decade in the state.

With the decision, owning a pit bull in the state of Maryland has become not only a much more serious responsibility, but also a potential liability. Both pit bull owners and landlords are now held accountable for a pit bull's actions. If a pit bull bites, the consequences and punishments are more serious for both owner and landlord.

As a result of the greater responsibility being laid on pit bull owners and landlords that have them on their property, animal rescue groups are afraid of the potential fallout that the decision will have on rescuing and adopting out pit bulls who wind up in animal shelters. The reality is that the decision has made owning a pit bull much more difficult, and has effectively created yet another barrier to adopting the breed.

While the effects of the Maryland decision will be seen primarily in Maryland at first, animal activists are worried about the potential effects that the decision will have on the rest of the country. If one state can rule a dog breed inherently dangerous, what's to stop another from doing the same? Maryland may have set a precedent for the rest of the country, where some areas already have existing discriminatory breed laws.

While the onus of raising a dog correctly falls squarely on the shoulders of the owner, the statistics surrounding pit bulls and attack-oriented incidents are pretty staggering. While each bite case is different, pit bulls do account for a large number of bites. The Center for Disease Control estimates that pit bulls accounted for 66 out of 238 dog bite cases that occurred between 1979 and 1996.

Where do you stand on the issue? Do you think pit bulls are inherently dangerous? Or is Maryland's ruling the epitome of breedism at its finest, setting an ugly precedent of the next wave of discriminatory laws against pits? Share your thoughts in a comment.

Author's profile photo
Ryan Karpusiewicz Ryan Karpusiewicz is the Assistant Editor, Lifestyle, for Digital Works @ NBC U, whose main…

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (36)

SnapMode Nikki
Ankle Biter'z are the dangerous breed'z! BAN ANKLE BITER'z!
SnapMode Nikki
This Breed is FAR from Vicious! Kill the owner, rehabillitate the Breed!
Anonymous (Unverified)
APBT's can be dangerous, and so can lots of other dogs, i wonder how many times a dogbite gets recorded as an "APBT", 75% of the world can't tell the difference between a pit and 15 other breeds. Don't believe me? take the pitbull identification test. I had 6 wrong answers and i own a pitbull.
Anonymous (Unverified)
I love the breed (pitbulls), as I am the owner of one and my son has them too. Any dog can and will bite if mistreated or trained up to be aggressive. It is the owners responsibility to take proper care and love the animal. They are definitly a lovable breed if given a chance. I am also speaking for Dobermans, Rottweilers and German shepard, as I have owned all of these breeds. My mother had a chihuaha that would bite your feet if you walked in her house!!! Hope I made my point on this.
Tom C (Unverified)
The statistic about the number of Pit Bull bites is meaningless if you don't present the % of dogs that are Pit Bulls in comparison? Of all the dogs that are put in a more likely position to bite -- neglect and poor training, trained and used as guards dogs, abandonment, etc...we need to know what % of these dogs are Pit Bulls in order to have the proper perspective to analyze this statistic. It is highly irresponsible to use statistics in the wrong context and without proper perspective. The media does this ALL the time to create headlines. You should know better before you publish something like this. If I told you that 90% of all dogs that are used as guard dogs or are abused severely in the US were Pit Bull or Pit Bull mixes, would that change your perspective that 66 out of 238 bites come from Pit Bulls? I imagine it would. All of this being said, Pit Bulls are certainly a "Bully Breed", strong and often dominant and assertive and for all of these reasons they should be taken very seriously in situations with children, strangers and other dogs until they can prove they are well adjusted and dependable. The same goes for many other large dog breeds.
Becky Livingston (Unverified)
My fiancee and I own two pitbulls, Remy and Ace, who are part of our family. We also have a 4-year-old son who absolutely adores them. No matter how rough he might play with them, they are always gentle and completely submissive with him. I trust my two dogs around him 100% and have never questioned that. PLEASE STOP DISCRIMINATING AGAINST MY FAMILY
Dottie (Unverified)
I think only an idiot would say that any dog breed is more dangerous than another.I had to have my face put back together at the age of 3 because of a bite from a Lab and my daughter was raised around pit bulls and was bit by a mutt dog at the age of 4 and again by a chow at the age of 7 and then was bit by a pit bull at the age of 10.I have been bitten other times by other dogs and at the age of 45 have never been bitten by a pit bull.All but one of those bites were from dogs that ran anywhere they pleased.The pit bull that bit my daughter was on a chain,in a fenced back yard and the kids had been told not to go in the back yard,but they did anyway and my child was wrong for her part in that.I fought to keep the dog from being put down and he was not put down. People need to be punished for not only their pit bulls but any dog that bites another person if that dog has not been treated badly by that person. People need to grow a brain and think about why any dog bites people.Not because they were born that way but because they were taught that behavior.Pit Bulls are animal aggressive not people aggressive by nature and heritage.I never had a human aggressive pit bull in over 18 years of no less than 3 pit bulls at one time. Why not take a look at all dog bites and all breeds even if the dog is a mutt and also look at the owners and how the dogs were raised?