Cat Litter Box Help 101

Published February 19, 2013

Flickr User alan_i_think

Which type of cat litter and litter box does your feline prefer?

Whenever I am chatting with a friend who is as passionate about cats as I am, I find that after kitty “bragging” discussions are over, our conversations invariably turn to the pros and cons of the brands and different types of litter boxes which will keep our kitties healthy and happy.

And once we get into it and deeply delve into the topic, it’s darned easy to spend hours on end exploring the optimal size and shape of a perfect litter box, whether it should be covered or uncovered, scooped automatically or manually, where it ideally should be located and, to avoid “accidents”, precisely just how many boxes are necessary.

When the litter box talkathon is finally exhausted, it is immediately followed with a philosophical discussion of the merits of clumping litter vs. non-clumping, scented or odorless, manufactured out of clay, corn, cedar chips, or any other material. When it comes to the topic of litter and litter boxes, cat people can really get into it. And with the huge variety of these essential sanitary necessities that are available on the market today, it can become truly overwhelming when cat servants are trying to make a decision about what products are most appropriate.

Since cleaning kitty’s toilet is not generally one of the top 10 favorite kitty keeping chores, to some extent I understand why some folks tell me they prefer the self-cleaning and self-flushing automatic litter boxes. This said, however, in this cat servant’s opinion, it’s equally important to monitor kitty’s output as it is to stay on top of their food and water intake. Therefore I am not convinced that automatic litter boxes are preferable to those we manually scoop. While "power" boxes do offer some convenience, they can prevent us from picking up on serious issues that may be lurking.  

One of the most common gripes I hear from cat keepers is that their cats are energetic “diggers” and make a huge mess by scattering litter all over the floor. And then there are those cats that prefer to pee standing up and leave puddles outside the box.

We solved the majority of these problems by using Clevercat litter boxes. Their high sides prevent spillage and the specially designed cover traps most of the litter that is kicked outside the box.  Following the equation of one litter box per cat plus one, we have two cats and three boxes. To keep both cats happy, one is uncovered and two are covered.

“Scented” litter is a product made to benefit the owner, not the cat. Most cats dislike scented litter, since their “scent” is preferable. Anyway, keeping litter boxes clean and fresh prevents nasty odors from accumulating.

What type of litter box and litter do your kitties prefer? Tell us in a comment.

Author's profile photo
Jo Singer

Shortly after retiring as a social worker and psychotherapist, I discovered my "writer's voice"…

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (10)

Anonymous (Unverified)
I have 4 cats and two boxes. We use potting soil. Much cheaper than litter, the kitties love to dig and dig. Then instead of throwing it away i dump in in the flower beds. Now I have lovely plants too. Oh and it covers up the kitty smell much better than litter plus i don't have to scoop it out. I just dump and wash the pans weekly. No chemicals at all.
rubykitten (Unverified)
My kitties get a little concerned if we use anything but the scented Fresh Step. I don't know if it's because they like the scent, or if they get worried we might be on a budget (might have less treats next!!) My kitties do seem to like sniffing things like flowers and other scents that don't seem like things kitties would like to smell. Then squint their eyes a little and make a dreamy face like "oh that smells purrty".
Rani (Unverified)
We have two cats and two litter pans, which they both share and couldn't care less as to which they use. They don't like pine litter or the newspaper-litter though otherwise, any brand is OK. When we first got Buster and slowly introduced him to Rao, his litter pan was in our bathroom. After he was acclimated into the household, though, we had trouble getting him adjusted to the litter being in the other bathroom. Jo advised me to move the pan across the house a short distance every few days, which worked great! Since they are happy and the pans are in little alcoves in the bathroom,I hesitate to rock the boat and buy enclosed pans or any fancy self-cleaning types that they might not like. In years past with cats past, I've had them divvy up the litter pans in different ways, such as everyone urinates in one and defecates in the other OR Cat #1 uses Litter Pan #1, Cat #2 uses Pan #2 etc. I've also had cats who protest "I don't care for this litter" by using the bathtub.
Abehs10 (Unverified)
Very interesting topic!! I live in a single home built like a double and have 7 cats. I have to admit I have litter boxes on all 3 floors of the house. Believe me when I say they use all of them. The ones in the basement are 2 very large uncovered litter boxes for those who do not want to be possibly trapped in a covered box. I also have two "regular boxes" for those who want privacy. One the main floor of the house there is just one "in case" they get caught between floors where they want to be. On the second floor there are 4 more boxes all covered. As for litter I believe unscented clumping is the best. The scent is put in there to please the owner and not the cat, matter of fact my cats won't go near a box with scented litter. Yes they are a lot of work but my pets are worth the time and effort. Oh and I should add I also have 3 dogs which get long fine with the cats.
Sharon from NY (Unverified)
I don't have room for three boxes and my two girls get along just fine with two. I use World's Best Cat Litter. I find that it works really well and they seem to like it. It doesn't scatter too much. Many cats do NOT like covered boxes because it keeps the "bad smell" in and mine are both uncovered at this time. I can't use litter catching mats because Stella is obsessed with scratching... outside the box before using it...and along the inside ... but never where she actually USES the box! I can always tell where she has gone because it is never covered up..I put down litter mats once...and had to take them away..she became obsessed with scratching it and dragging it (and the box...) well it was a disaster. I'd rather sweep up a little litter every day. Stella has some serious OCD going on there. Shadow, on the other hand, MUST completely cover everything and generally makes nice, neat pyramids in the box.
VickiJasch (Unverified)
Our cat has a regular litter box and we use liners in it also to help with clean-up. As far as litter is concerned, I usually buy the clump free deodorizing kind. He seems to like it.
PamH
Last November, I fostered to adopt a sweet 6YO cat named Sophia as a companion for my 16YO Maine coon, Sandy. Sandy is very laid back as you can imagine and Sophia is very easy-going. They were introduced to each other and there was no hiss, no ears back, no tail twitching, nothing. Everything was great for a week and suddenly, Sophia started avoiding the litter boxes completely. I was using Arm & Hammer and read about the scent possibly being an issue. I first removed the litterbox liners I was using to see if that would help; next was a switch to TidyCat which Sophia had been using while at the rescue organization. That helped with solids but she was still peeing outside the box. I use cheap ($2.50) shower liners under the litterboxes to protect the floor so fortunately, she was peeing on this but it still was at least once a day. I clean the boxes 2x/day so I started cleaning more frequently. That also helped. Finally, I called the rescuer for her suggestions. She suggested getting puppy pads and putting them around the litterboxes so if she peed, it would be an easy clean-up. Surprisingly, at least to me, that worked! Sophia scratches the pads, messing them up, but hasn't had an "accident" in about six weeks. After a couple of weeks, I completed her adoption. It's strange but it's working! She's snuggled up in my lap as I type. :)