Pet Adoption Process: Finding the Right Shelter Dog for Your Family

Getty Images

In the market for a new dog? Learn the ins and outs of pet adoption and how to find a shelter dog you'll love!

Congratulations! You've made the big decision to adopt a dog from your local animal shelter. Your new four-legged friend can bring years of love and joy to your family if - and it's a big if - you choose the right dog from those that are available. Read on for some tips to help ensure that the shelter dog you select will be right for you and your family.

Bring the kids -- but not right away. Although kids should help select the new dog, parents should make an initial visit to the animal shelter on their own. That way, parents can look at the available dogs and talk with shelter personnel without being subjected to the entreaties of their children. "It will be very hard for you to ignore your child's pleas for a very cute dog that would not be a good match for the family's needs," says dog trainer Colleen Pelar, author of Living With Kids and Dogs ... Without Losing Your Mind (C&R Publishing). "Together with the shelter staff, parents should narrow their choices down to three dogs before bringing the kids."

Ask questions. During the initial visit, take the time to talk with personnel about any shelter dogs that interest you. "The shelter staff should be able to give you information about a dog's activity level, sociability, tolerance for physical handling, ability to bounce back from stress, and other traits," says Pelar, who lives in Springfield, Virginia. "These assessments cannot guarantee a dog's future behavior, but they do provide some detailed information that can help you choose a dog that will fit in well with your family."

Look for an extrovert. Great family dogs generally love being with people, especially children. "One of the best ways to tell if a dog likes kids is to have the parents on one side of the room being quiet and the kids acting like kids on the other side of the room," says Pelar. "The dog that gravitates happily over to the kids and stays with them is a wonderful choice for a family."

Bypass the shy guy. The timid little darling who shrinks from your hand may draw your sympathy, but he shouldn't be your choice. "If a shelter dog hangs back in the corner of a kennel, choose another dog," says Pelar. "Look for a dog that really enjoys interacting with all the family members and one that recovers quickly when something startling occurs, such as a noisy argument over whose turn it is to empty the dishwasher. You want a dog that can adapt quickly."

Nix the possessive type. You should expect your kids to share their stuff, and you should expect the same from your dog. "Dogs that growl, snarl or snap when they have something of value, such as a bone, are difficult to manage around children," warns Pelar. "Ask the shelter staff if the dog has been tested for 'resource guarding' and do not adopt one that shows aggression if you try to take something away."

Don't rush. Finding the right shelter dog is an enterprise endeavor to be approached with care. Making the right decision can mean years of treasured memories for your family, while making the wrong choice can quickly lead to heartbreak. Make sure your kids understand that finding the right dog might take some time, including more than one visit to the shelter. Better yet, rein in their expectations: "Tell the kids that we're just going to look to lessen their disappointment if the family leaves without adopting a dog," suggests Pelar.

Award-winning writer Susan McCullough's books include Housetraining For Dummies, Senior Dogs For Dummies and Beagles For Dummies (all, Wiley). She lives with her husband, daughter and Golden Retriever in Vienna, Virginia. Visit her website at www.susanmc.com.

Susan McCullough Award-winning writer Susan McCullough's books include Housetraining For Dummies, Senior Dogs For…

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (4)

Anonymous (Unverified)
the shy dog can easily turn into the comedian once home and adjusted. the great dog can turn into a resource guarder once in the home. you never know exactly what you're getting because a shelter environment gives you no real ability to see the dog's personality. however!!!! almost every dog can be brought home, and worked with right from the start. an article bracing families for the personality changes would be more helpful. i have fostered more than 50 dogs straight from a kill shelter. i have adopted several. my adopted ones are all or have been pit type dogs. the shy one? running around like a 6 month old puppy. the perfect one? started off as a resource guarder but responds to making everything mine. then she's fine. the hyperactive one? snoozes most of the day...turns out he has separation anxiety and was traumatized by the shelter environment. prepare to be unprepared and expect what you didn't expect. a dog needs SIX months in a stable environment with CONSISTENT training. never leave any child alone with a dog of any size or type. kids are curious, and often inadvertently cruel or make mistakes that an adult needs to correct. the shy one is often the best one once you get him home and in a stable environment. My best fosters and forever dogs started off as the shy one in the corner that you're supposed to bypass. this article was written by someone who just rephrased old hash. there is no real experience reflected in this article.
Anonymous (Unverified)
If everyone bypasses the shy dog, it's doomed. They can be some of the sweetest lap dogs in time. I agree on the agressive tip, but don't bypass a dog just because it's quiet. Give all types a chance! Just because a dog seems like an extrovert doesn't mean it's the best dog in the shelter. I find this article only helpful for families with young hyper children; not childless couples, families with older kids, or the elderly.
Anonymous (Unverified)
so if everyone is told to bypass the shy dog, will it ever be adopted? seems like a sad ending for that pooch :(
Anonymous (Unverified)
And folks? A pure breed doesn't necessarily mean a dog is better. Take a look at the mutts, too. I have three mixed breed dogs that are some of the best I've ever had, and they don't have near the health trouble as pure breeds I've owned.