Horse Slaughter Ban Lifted: Horse Meat May Be Coming Soon

Published December 1, 2011

Flickr User lovelychristy02

Horse slaughter ban lifted: President Obama recently signed a bill that lifted the five-year-old ban on horse slaughter in the United States.

As a passionate horse lover, I can hardly contain my outrage after learning yesterday that, in line with a new bill signed by President Obama, our beloved American horses soon may be butchered legally in the United States to be used as meat for human consumption.

The most recent threat to American horses can be attributed to a new bill which resulted in the horse slaughter ban being lifted. In spite of President Obama’s 2008 campaign promise to protect horses from this outrage, our President has gone back on his word by signing the new bill passed by Congress on November 15. With the five-year-old ban on horse slaughter lifted, horse slaughterhouses may begin to crop up once again in the United States (although none currently exist). Supposedly, the bill was passed (as part of a funds allocation effort) to keep the Government open and funded until mid-December.

While horse meat may in theory could be coming to a store near you, the lawmakers, in their haste to pass the bill, did not include funds that would be allocated to pay for horse meat inspectors. As a result, the USDA is left trying to find a way to pick up the tab in this department. With no funds allocated for this ever-important inspection step in the slaughter process (without inspectors meat couldn't be approved for sale), tax payers could find themselves picking up the bill, with annual costs of between three and five million dollars. So much for being cost effective!

Horse Slaughter Ban Lifted: A Long History of Debate

This most current bill marks yet another notch in the belt that is a long history of debate over horse slaughter.

In 2006, anti-horse slaughter proponents were able to successfully get legislation passed through Congress which effectively cut off all funding for horse meat inspections, even though legislation to ban all horse slaughter in general had previously failed. Without horse meat inspectors, the sale of horse meat for human consumption was banned, and without any way to profit the three remaining horse slaughterhouses in the United States were closed in 2007.

Pro-slaughter proponents, however, claim that the ban on horse slaughter inadvertently caused a huge rise in the number of abandoned and neglected horses.

Horse Slaughter Ban Lifted: The Aftermath

As a result of the ban being lifted, horse slaughter advocates are hurrying to get a plant opened within 30 to 90 days in either North Dakota, Wyoming, Missouri or Nebraska, if state approval is given.

Should this come to fruition, up to 200,000 horses a year could be slaughtered in the United States. While the majority of their meat would be shipped to foreign countries, including Europe, Asia and Japan, some of the horse meat could be served in the United States. Rep. Sue Wallis (R-Wyoming) is hoping that horse meat could be served in her state to prisoners and school children.

The Truth About Horse Slaughter, and the Horse Slaughter Ban Being Lifted

Horses have never been raised for meat; they have been raised as companion animals who perform countless services to mankind. And the initial preconceptions of horse slaughter, such as the idea that horses slaughtered for meat are being put down to end their suffering, are just not true.

According to Charmaine Jens, Public Relations Representative for Americans Against Horse Slaughter, the truth is that the majority of horses slaughtered for their meat are not the old, infirm, neglected horses that are no longer useful, a smoke-and-mirrors perception which has become one of the popular party-lines for those in support of horse slaughter.

These horses are purchased by “killer buyers” who work for the foreign-owned horse slaughter industry. Healthy horses bring the highest price per pound. Incredibly, The USDA Guidelines for Handling and Transporting Equines to Slaughter state that more than 92 percent of horses slaughtered are “in good to excellent condition.” Sadly, these slaughter victims are the horses that can be re-trained, re-homed and once again become a precious companion animal.

Horse Slaughter Ban Lifted: The Fight to End the Practice Continues

The fight to prevent this travesty from happening is far from over. Horse and animal lovers who abhor the idea of horses being slaughtered for meat for human consumption and want to help should contact their Congressman immediately, imploring them to co-sponsor Senate bill S.1176 and House bill 2966.

Do you support President Obama in his decision to sign the bill Congress passed? Leave a comment and share your opinion.

Author's profile photo
Jo Singer

Shortly after retiring as a social worker and psychotherapist, I discovered my "writer's voice"…

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (101)

xgnslngr (Unverified)
What's next, our dogs and cats? If there is money in it, it will happen. Certainly we have enough cultures here that would supply the demand. When have we gone too far? Horses to me are like my dogs, part of my family. Could you butcher your family pet for food? Another promise Obama has failed to perform. With his economic policies, maybe he sees a need to produce alternative food sources...
Anonymous (Unverified)
Just because horses are slaughtered does not mean that all that meat goes for human consumption. If there is not a demand for the product then it would not be sold. Everyone is entitled to there own taste for food and should be allowed to choose as they want. The biggest single horse breeder in the nation is the US government and every self righteous do gooder that condemns management of a species by eliminating the ones no one wants needs to put their money where there mouths are and pay the hundreds of thousands of dollars spent annually by our government to manage all the unwanted wild horse population. The BLM does nothing to control all the wild horse bands yet the domestic horse industry takes all the heat for unwanted horses. There should be a voluntary donation line item on the income tax form for the support of the wild horse herds and only the number of horses that this income raises should be allow to survive. The populace as a whole does not need to support unwanted wild horses. It is not the money to the horse owner that is driving the horse slaughter, because a good slaughter horse does not even bring $100 a head. It takes over $500 a year to feed that same horse. So you need to stop condemning responsible people that enjoy working with and managing domestic horse. Clean up your own stables first with the unwanted BLM horses.
Shirley (Unverified)
Again, Obama has reached a new low. Hey Woppie, why not have the gals of The View over for some horse with a side of muzzel? Minus Elisabeth Hasselbeck. Ill bet Joy loves horse. I would say she looks like one but i cannot because horses are beautiful. Cant say the same for Joy. See if Obama and Michelle want to join. Now, I understand american horses are shipped to Mexico & Canada for slaughter and i think that is the most inhumane, confusing time of a poor horses life. Breaders just throw these majestic animals away when they no longer serve their perpose and think only of the bottom line. The dollar which isnt worth much now days. I love dogs, cats, horses plus. If you have ever owned horses, dogs or cats you would understand. Cows and chickens are bread for slaughter. Horses, dogs and cats are not!!!!!!!!!!!!!
steve2 (Unverified)
All types of animals were raised for thousands of years for food, clothing, work andplay. This includes cows, dogs, cats and horses and others. Shame ion us to put an animalon off limits as a food supply. When half the worlds populatiion is starving. Besides,Dog is good!
Anonymous (Unverified)
Ummm, the two bills you referenced at the end of the article haven't beem acted upon since their introduction to House and Senate in 2011. And I can't seem to find the name/number of the bill Obama has allegedly signed into law that is the basis for your article. Please provide bill number, and date of signage into law.
Anonymous (Unverified)
stupid stupid stupid
Anonymous (Unverified)
Before you come out swinging left and right you should get some more information. Please consider this: Quote: :Q: Isn’t it true with closure of U.S. slaughterhouses, unwanted horses are now protected from death by slaughter? A: No. This is one of the most common misconceptions held by those not fully informed. Approximately 138,000 U.S. horses were transported to Canada and Mexico for slaughter in 2010, almost identical to the approximate number of horses slaughtered here annually in years just before 2007, when the U.S. slaughterhouses closed. Between 2006 and 2010, the number of American horses exported increased by 148 percent to Canada, and a staggering 660 percent to Mexico. EndQuote The difference: A 2006 ban on funding for U.S. Department of Agriculture inspection of horses intended for slaughter means that horses are transported extremely long distances to slaughter plants out of the country. By one estimate, these horses are trucked an average of 25 hours before reaching their final destination...." If we a a society can't provide for all the horses that are getting 'produced' by irresponsible breeders we at lease need to provide for an end of live in dignity. For more information please go to http://www.equisearch.com/horses_riding_training/western/the-unwanted-horse-whats-his-fate/2/