Feeding Picky Eaters, My Cats

Published December 16, 2010
There is nothing quite as exasperating than being owned by a couple of cats who act as if they are hungry but keep refusing the nutritious grainless canned cat food I serve them. And there is nothing more rewarding when they chow down with delight. But recently our two Oriental Shorthair cats, Hubble and Hush Puppy, have developed an overwhelming "jones "for a variety of cat food that I, as a most discerning cat foodie, consider unacceptable kitty "junk food." Mea culpa! Worse, I'm the one that got them started on it, out of pure frustration. Cats gotta eat! To top it all off, Hubble, our white Oriental is undergoing extensive tests to get to the bottom of his recent bout of vomiting, and is also being treated with antibiotics for a mild respiratory infection which must be given with food. You can only imagine my frustration! After sniffing the venison, duck or lamb I offer, they just walk away, turning up their noses in disgust. Even the sample of a highly nutritious raw food diet made for felines to which our veterinarian received rave reviews from clients, was instantly rejected. I have been known to even get down on my knees begging them to surrender, whetting their appetites with turkey, chicken or beef baby food, since cats cannot go for extended periods of time refusing food without potential problems. Whatever is a cat mom to do? I was forced to take action at the local supermarket. My head was spinning from reading all the labels of commercial cat food. But honestly; wasn't I there in the first place to find a food they would more than likely devour with gusto? It must have taken me close to an hour to settle on a brand. While the first ingredient on the label was poultry broth and by-by-products, and it contained wheat gluten, which I don't agree with, I grabbed several cans of different flavors just to see how they would respond. Both cats rapidly polished off their dinners leaving not even a dollop of gravy, licking their chops with delight as they purred away. Was I enabling two feline junk food addicts? But 15 minutes after Hubble polished off his breakfast, up it came. I am right back to square one! What am I to do? Share your thoughts in a comment.
Author's profile photo
Jo Singer

Shortly after retiring as a social worker and psychotherapist, I discovered my "writer's voice"…

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (8)

Reno (Unverified)
My mother can share your frustrations. Her cat is also extremely picky and goes on these binges where he acts hungry but will not eat. It is on those occasions where she does the same as you.....she feeds Friskies or some other junk brand. Then he will go back to Wellness, or Royal Canin or something else nutritious. I, myself, have been truly blessed with 7 cats that will eat anything I think. LOL They eat the Royal Canin Special 33 whcih was developed for cats with sensitive stomachs/digestive tracts, and has SIGNIFICANLTY reduced the vomiting in my house. Good luck, Jo and glows and headbonks to you.....
Buttons Daddy (Unverified)
It's not uncommon for cats to have issues when you switch their food, especially if it's not done gradually. The best advice I've gotten is to start by giving 2/3 of the old food and 1/3 of the new and gradually increasing the new food so their systems get used to it. It's not always possible if the cats reject the old food, but maybe if the old and new are mixed together it might work.
Ruth UK (Unverified)
Over 36 years of sharing our lives with cats we've had some picky eaters too and it's very worrying when a cat won't eat as they get ill so quickly. Sometimes you have to resort to something tasty but not as nutritious,just to sort of 'kick start' their appetites again. It's a sort of support club in the cat food aisles in Supermarkets, fellow sufferers standing sighing and reading labels lol I've had many an interesting conversation with other cat people tearing their hair out over what cat food to try !
Iniki (Unverified)
We have very little problem with our cats. Almost all of them are rescues and seem to just be happy to be fed. They are not fussy. They enjoy boiled chicken once a month and also cook liver once a month. Sometimes they get well cooked ground beef and even raw chicken necks occasionally but for the most part they like their canned food and dry also. The older two cats get special food adn some of that is mixed with the regular cans of food so all the cats get a taste. We also sprinkle sunflower oil on their food about once a week. We use it very sparingly and they love it. Their coats are shiney and they are happy and full of love and energy.
fourhorsegal
I guess every species has it's likes and dislikes. My cat will eat just about anything. But since he is at an advanced age, I feed him food for senior indoor cats. He seems to like it because he sure hasn't lost any weight.
Donna9331
After reading an eye opening article that dry food isn't necessarily best for our cats, I bought canned food. I have 6 cats. I give them a can of catfood. There are LEFTOVERS. What is wrong with that picture? I buy more expensive catfood in littler cans. 6 cats...still leftovers. =\ I buy GROUND TURKEY....cook it up. Throw it in the garbage. They won't touch the stuff. Fortunately, the most difficult tummy problem I deal with is if one eats too fast, they barf (and whose cat doesn't barf on occasion?) I found a bag of IAMS marked to 1/2 price because only the outside of the bag was ripped...they went nuts over it. For a while. Now they prefer the cheapest cat food I can find. I've decided for my kits variety is the spice of life. I even bought my sr. citizen Pirate, Filet Minon and something Fancy Feast dry. He ate that like crazy. For a few days. Now he's back to the regular dry. . I think...in these economic times, I'm gonna keep hitting the 'sale' rack at the store where I work and buy them still intact bags of "whatever" marked down by 1/2 (that I couldn't afford full price)...and relish the experience every time the outside stray, Buster, downs whatever I choose to give him. :) At least I have ONE cat (well, he's not really mine, I guess) that will eat anything!) LOL CATS!
jmuhj (Unverified)
PS Another thing that helps with some cats is to use elevated feeders, available at http://www.DrsFosterSmith.com and other cat supply businesses. Some cats eat too quickly and then regurg; others have problems eating from bowls on the floor. Good luck!