The Scoop on Dog Poop: Rethinking Plastic Bags

Published October 9, 2012

Getty Images

A responsible dog owner cleans up after her dogs. But is she using a plastic bag?

Do you ever think about what happens to that dog poop you pick up in a plastic grocery bag and toss in the trash? (Kudos to you for actually picking up after your dog!) Though cleaning up dog waste is an important step to prevent the spread of disease, there’s more scoop on dog poop than you might realize.

The average dog eliminates between a half pound and three quarters of a pound per day, which amounts to about ten tons of waste per year. (A trash audit in the Bay Area discovered that dog waste accounts for nearly 4% of total landfill waste.) A key problem in the landfill poop pileup is that the typical grocery store plastic bags most of us use for dog waste take hundreds of years to degrade. The waste is basically being preserved in plastic and clogging the landfills.

Instead of using “time capsule” plastic bags, consider investing in bags that break down over time like biodegradable, compostable or flushable bags. There are many options available on the market, with costs per bag as low as .06 cents. Most biodegradable bags dissolve when exposed to the elements (the good ones can even do so in an anaerobic landfill environment), leaving the waste to break down naturally. Compostable poop bags can be used in back yard compost bins or at municipal composting facilities, though dog waste contains parasites that make it unsuitable for use near edible plants or in topsoil. Finally, flushable bags are an option for homes with enough flushing power and “healthy” sewer lines.

It’s not fun to think about dog poop (and it's even less fun to pick it up!), but as any responsible dog guardian knows, it’s important. Spend a few extra minutes considering how you scoop your poop, and the planet will thank you.

Author's profile photo
Victoria Schade Victoria Schade has been a dog trainer for over eleven years. During that time she has worked on…

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (7)

Anonymous (Unverified)
Great! We are all accountable for our pets waste. It does not make sense to pick it up in a last-for-ever plastic bag. Thanks. www.elliescrate.com
Barb (Unverified)
It's a common misconception that solid waste in a landfill *should* decompose. But it is *wrong.* Waste decomposition in a landfill just creates methane (a potent GHG). So to really be green do NOT use "decomposing" bags. And if you live where waste is incinerated (like I do in NJ), just try for #1 or #2 plastic bags (the recycle code) as they burn cleanest. Most states prohibit flushing of pet waste as the bacteria is different than human waste so the water treatment plants are not set up for pet waste & can contaminate the fresh water systems. The uncertainty of the bacteria also is why home composting is against regulation (it's not that it can't compost; and yes do NOT use that compost for growing food!!)
Petside Victoria (Unverified)
Glad to see that this very important topic is generating some interest! As for the "shocking inaccuracy" of suggesting composting as an option, please refer to this USDA study about composting Alaskan sled dog waste: ftp://ftp-fc.sc.egov.usda.gov/AK/Publications/dogwastecomposting2.pdf Home composting is an option as well: http://www.sierraclubgreenhome.com/go-green/composting/environmentally-friendly-dog-waste-disposal/ Unfortunately, there is no easy solution to this problem, but I stand by my suggestion to avoid plastic grocery store bags and seek out more Earth friendly options.
patrickb (Unverified)
I think the main point behind the article is pick up your dogs poop and dispose of it as best you can. I can't tell you how many people let their dog poop in my front yard (or worse the sidewalk) and leave it there and think nothing of it. Like my front yard is their dogs toilet. One time I ran out and told the person to pick it up and he had nothing to get it with so I said "use your hands". Needless to say he kept walking. Letting your dog poop in someone else's yard and cutting in line at a grocery store - worst things ever!
Joel Bittner (Unverified)
This blog is shockingly inaccurate. You should NEVER, ever compost dog poop. This is dangerous and Charles comments in this blog are 100% accurate. Furthermore, go ask a commercial compost facility if they will accept dog poop in a ASTM D6400 bag. They will say "No Thanks". Furthermore, any bag manufacturer that is claiming their bag will break down in a landfill is using oxo-degradable additives that are high in lead content and will absolutely do more harm that good to the integrity of the ground soil and water. The BEST eco-solution is, stick with bags made using 100% recycled content, or bags using a hybrid blend of recycled materials and sustainable resins like the bio-buddy product. And last, stop paying over $.05/bag for these products. Do your homework, and you will find these bags can be purchased for as little as $.02/ea.
Rule 56 (Unverified)
Uh...no. Pet waste, including dog and cat poop, is perfectly compostable. What's shocking is how many people, including apparently you, who think the only way to dispose of it is to bury it under tons of earth in a landfill. As if that solves anything. I've been composting my dog's poop for years. A compost pile's heat and the microbial competition it fosters are more than a match for any pathogens in the animal's poop. The only question is whether you want to use that compost to fertilize food crops or just your lawn and ornamental garden.
tony (Unverified)
Plastic bag is not eco-friendly to our environment. We need to find a new way to solve this problem in order to protect our home town. We're the professional manufacturer of biodegradable and compostable resin and bags. I think you may help us to find the right partner in this field. We established own factory, comes up with ten thousand tons of biodegradable raw materials annually. To guarantee the product quality, we take strict testing in every step from materials purchasing to final production. We can supply 100% biodegradable & compostable MBM-CF resin and its biodegradable bag which meet the standard of EN13432 and ASTM D6400. Please visit our website www.mbm-bio.com for more information. We need your help to find the best partner to fulfill the purpose of reducing plastic bag, It will be happy to have cooperation with you in some particular fields in your country. May you help us to do this thing? If you have the interest, pls don't hesitate to contact me. Tony Manager of Marketing PH: (86) 10 67832216 FX: (86) 10 67832216 WB: www.mbm-bio.com EM: zulu.casic@gmail.com P.O: 100176 Skype: tony.jinjin