Cat or Dog? What Your Pet Says About Your Personality

Published August 2, 2010
Cat lovers might just start revving up their purring engines, and begin grinning like a Cheshire cat while reading the release of a recent study made by a group of scientists in Great Britain. It just may prove a theory that cat owners are smarter than dog owners. Hey folks, I promise you that I didn't bribe the research scientists to ensure that their result validated what most cat people suspect. They simply set out to prove their hypothesis and accomplished their mission; noting that dog owners are just not quite as intelligent as those of us who are owned by felines. According to a report from the Daily Mail, researchers working on this extensive study, designed to learn which kind of pet the British prefer, discovered that cat owners are, for the most part, more intelligent than folks who love dogs. Results demonstrated that the people in the study who had college degrees, (who may at first glance be generally considered "smarter"), were 36 percent more likely to be owned by a cat, than those who did not obtain a college degree. However, in all fairness to dog lovers, these results could have been based upon the assumption that perhaps college graduates work longer hours. And since cats generally are considered lower maintenance pets than their canine counterparts, this group of "Brits" chose felines as their furry companions. But what about people who choose to share their hearts and homes with both species? That is the $64 million question, as far as I am concerned. Into which category do these folks fall as far as intelligence is concerned? A great answer to this mystery was given by Kathy Steuber, owned by Finley, a chocolate Labradoodle, along with two rescued cats. She thinks that her pets may actually be smarter than she is, and said, "I'm outnumbered by my furry friends, and sometimes they do gang up on me."' In the United States, a recent study examined personality types in relationship to pet preference. In the Gosling-Potter Personality Project held at the University of Texas at Austin, led by psychologist Sam Gosling, a group of researchers asked thousands of volunteer participants whether they preferred cats or dogs. In the same online questionnaire, they were asked to rate their personality traits in five areas: neuroticism, agreeableness, extroversion, openness, and conscientiousness. The study results demonstrated that those who consider themselves "dog people" ranked higher in the area of extroversion, conscientiousness and agreeableness. Feline lovers, however, ranked higher in the areas of openness and neuroticism, which for the purposes of the study translate into "quirkiness, creativity and contemplation." In an interview with CNN, Dr. Gosling remarked, "Agreeableness and extroversion- dogs are companionable, they hang out, they like to be with you, they like your company, whereas cats like it for as long as they want it, and then they're off." However, Dr. Gosling added that some folks might consider a dog's incessant sniffing as a neurotic trait. Additionally, Gosling suggested that the study should be taken with a grain of salt, and told CNN, "it means that if you knew nothing else about them, that would be your best guess." The complete results of the team's findings will be published in the scientific Journal, Anthrozoos. So are cat people really both more intelligent but also more neurotic than dog people? Leave a comment with your opinions. Photo via.
Author's profile photo
Jo Singer

Shortly after retiring as a social worker and psychotherapist, I discovered my "writer's voice"…

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (8)

Sheena (Unverified)

I own two dogs and one cat, while my sister owns 5 cats and 0 dogs and is a stuck up bitch. So knowing this, ima have to side with the dogs, so sorry Gabriel(my cat)

orangeupurple (Unverified)

yes

eeee (Unverified)

I own 5 cats and 2 dogs, and I agree completely with both the "more intelligent" and the "more neurotic" conclusions. (Having said that, it's posts like the one from "Sabu" that give cat owners a bad name... even amongst other cat owners.)

As to the debate going on below about cats vs. dogs:
To Anonymous 11:06 - dogs may occasionally be messy, but are not inherently unclean. In fact, the main objection I've heard to cats is that they walk in the litter box (which, after one use, is "contaminated" with urine and fecal residue even if scooped scrupulously) and then walk on counters, tables, beds, chairs, laps, etc. Dogs don't spend as much time grooming themselves, but they also don't yak up hairballs as a result of swallowing all that hair. And the "coming back time and again" is indicative of a dog's loyalty and devotion to its owner; most abused dogs learn to stay at a safe distance (when possible) from their abusers, but will usually not abandon them and only very rarely turn on them. This faithfulness and unconditional love is why so many people love dogs so much.

To Mdmill: I found a stray dog several years ago, and when I finally contacted the "owners," they seemed reluctant to claim her. Seems that she had been owned by the man's father, and when the father (who lived alone) had passed away of a heart attack, it went unknown for two days. During that time, this adorable little ball of affectionate fur had, yes indeed, EATEN (parts of) her owner's body, and the deceased man's son did not even want to LOOK at the dog. His wife informed me that they were going to take the pup to the pound; I offered to go ahead and keep her, even though it was a bit weird. What surprised me most was that the man had only been dead for two days when someone came looking for him, but the dog (a toy poodle) had already munched - even cats will usually hold out for three or four days before the hunger takes over!

Debby Manansala (Unverified)
I have 3 cats (all belonged to daughters who have since left home) and feel that due to long hours at work, sharing a home with felines is much more humane than sharing a home with a dog. Dogs are more dependent on human interaction. Over the summer when I am off work I get the grand dog! I'm able to spend as much time with him as he needs and am able to exercise him twice a day. Would I want him year round as a pet? Yes! Would it be fair to him? NO! If we are looking at choices of pets as being a 'marker' of intelligence then we must take in all of the considerations. Conscientious pet owners place their pet's needs above our own 'pet desires'!
Fun Questionnaire (Unverified)
My vote goes to Dog! I don't like cats, as they always cry at nights. Dogs love humans, they even keep track of humans, provide security..feel for humans, love to play with us..what not. I love Dogs a lot.Thanks for sharing this article! Fun Questionnaire
Anonymous
CATS=beautiful, clean, quiet (well, sorta), intelligent, selective, agile, strong, fast... (dogs)= very unclean, slobber and mess everywhere, come back time after time even if someone kicks them; not too swift! I think that just about says what's printable.
Mdmill (Unverified)
Dogs = find deceased master and will lie next to them, never leaving their side sometimes to the point of their own starvation, displaying the utmost in love and loyalty. Cats = find deceased master and think "hmmm...lunch!"