Are Cats Manipulative?

Published February 28, 2011
While I simply love my husband Marty to death, we don't always see eye to eye about everything, especially when it comes to understanding feline behavior. The other day when I shared the story about my dilemma concerning Hush Puppy, our extremely finicky cat and how I discovered that bribing him with treats gets him to eat his food, Marty had a totally different take on Hush Puppy's apparent compliance. And mind you, while I don't recommend this highly unorthodox method, so far, knocking wood, it has been quite successful. I think of it as rewarding him for good behavior, but my husband considers him to be "playing" me. In my opinion, just the concept of a cat "playing" someone is outrageous. While they are highly intelligent little predators, I don't think of them as devious. Actually, in my many years of experience of cat keeping, I find them to be rather "up-front" in sharing their wishes and in their purrsonal interactions with me. When Hush Puppy sits gazing lovingly up at me, in front of the cabinet in which treats we keep their treats, I think that "please give me a goodie," is all he is saying. There is nothing covert about his behavior. He is simply being polite. Marty, on the other hand thinks this is manipulative and I am too easily seduced by his charming manners. Since I have willingly taken on the role of cat servant, devoting hours on end doting on them, thinking up ways to please them, I consider myself, at least in our household, to be more expert in understanding the language of our felines, which is always direct! Now I am not casting any dispersion on my husband's capacity to love our two delightful furry friends. I don't doubt for a moment that they both hold a place in his heart beyond measure. When they rub up against him and curl up in his lap, he gets this goofy look on his face with a smile that beams from ear to ear. He so enjoys their company, and they, his. Until fairly recently, Hush Puppy had been somewhat aloof toward his human "dad" but lately he has been showing him an abundance of trust and adoration, hanging out with him watching television. But I think this highly sensitive feline would be rather upset, if for a moment he thought that Marty doubted Hush Puppy's motives by the ways in which he shows him his affection, don't you agree? Do leave a comment and share your opinion! Image Source: Marty and Hush Puppy, by Jo Singer
Author's profile photo
Jo Singer

Shortly after retiring as a social worker and psychotherapist, I discovered my "writer's voice"…

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (6)

nessa (Unverified)
not only are cats manipulative they are possesive. my cat patty believes everything that comes in the house is hers. she sit's on everything. and gets mad if you try to move it. if you dont pet her when she wants you to you will not be able to pet her when YOU want to.and if i call patty and my other cat diana comes patty gets mad and jumps down and slaps diana as if to say she didnt call YOU she called ME so get on beey**ch!i just love them so much!
Reno (Unverified)
I absolutely think they are manipulating, but I love them for it. :)
Iniki (Unverified)
Oh I think they are manipulative when it suits them. Usually they can get what they want easily by just loving us but when they feel the need they can be so very manipulative. Case in point: Cat wants the outdoor enclosure opened. Momma says no....cat goes into the bathroom and rings the wind chimes beside the cat enclosure window. Momma ignores. Cat thinks.... momma goes to get the mail....cat dances and cries and repeats the wind chime trick. Poppa opens the window. Momma is not a push over but poppa is....cat knows it.
fourhorsegal
Considering the fact that I know our horses manipulate us, (not opinion, a fact)I would say that cats are gifted the same. When it is feeding time the horses will go to the fence by their buckets and make all kind of noise. Even if they have just been fed, they see my hubby coming home from work and will go to the fence, stand by their buckets, and lie like a dog. Just my take on the matter.
Ruth (Unverified)
Manipulative? nope..we are thier servants and we serve them what they want. We don't own cats, they own us. So with that being said, Jo you are only doing what cat people do best..serving your cats like they trained you to do. Don't feel bed, we're all in the same boat..hehehehe
jmuhj (Unverified)
Well, it's all a matter of PURRspective, isn't it? ;) For me, cats are the ultimate givers of unconditional love and loyalty. My torti, for instance, does a prancing dance while rubbing on me, purring, and smiling. She doesn't want a thing for it -- she just loves me and is overjoyed, and wants to share it. When I'm down, my tuxedo Persian-mix rescue girl is right there by my side, very concerned and very affectionate. "Manipulative"? Well, it's all in how the beholder sees it. I agree with you, though, Jo ;)