AP-Petside Poll: Keeping Breedism at Bay

Published February 1, 2011

According to a recent AP-Petside.com poll, all breeds of dogs are not considered equally. Some people go as far as to say that certain breeds should be banned entirely. You walk into your local animal shelter looking to adopt a cute, friendly pup. The decision is between a poodle and a pit bull: Which would you choose?

According to a recent AP-Petside.com poll, all breeds of dogs are not considered equally. Some people go as far as to say that certain breeds should be banned entirely.

Fortunately, however, when asked, 60% of people said that all breeds should be allowed in residential communities.

At 38%, however, there is still a considerable minority who think some breeds should be banned.

Wondering which breed was most often chosen to be banned by those who think it's an acceptable practice? You guessed it- the pit bull, with a whopping 85%. Rottweilers were a long way away with 23%, followed by Dobermans at 8% and German Shepherds with 4%.

Fifty-three of pet owners say that they are a safe breed for residential neighborhoods, while 43% believe they are too dangerous.

However, younger people are coming around to pitties. The poll showed that 76% of people under 30 say pit bulls are safe, but only 37% of seniors did. While 64% of urbanite pet owners are more likely to believe pit bulls are safe, suburbanites were at 52%, and those in rural areas at 49%.

Although all the recent attention pit bulls have gotten is setting them up for future acceptance, any breed that has been previously recognized as dangerous has a lot to overcome. In fact, 28% of people polled believe that some dog breeds are truly dangerous, regardless of how they are trained or cared for.

However, at 71%, the majority choose not to judge the dog by its breed and say that all are safe as long as they are correctly trained.

The poll shows that 7% of people believe that any type of dog used for violence or fighting should be banned while 2% want to outlaw any large dog. As a society, are we judging dogs based on breed rather than individual temperament? Are we breedist?

Do you think any breed can result in an obedient dog with the right training and care? Or do you think whole breeds can be grouped together? Let us know in a comment.

Leave a Comment

Enter your information below or log in to skip these fields.
No account? Sign up here.
* indicates a required field.
(will appear with your comment)
For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.
(will not be published)
For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.

Comments (15)

Anonymous (Unverified)

Pitt bulls are not absolutely bad animals, BUT I seldom hear anything about the instinct hard wired into them by generations of selective breeding for ferocity. People are idiots if they think every pitty can be tamed through training. I wouldn't risk my toddler on it! (DogTrainer)

Anonymous
I just love this breed of dog. I am such a big fan of it. There is nothing better. orlando drunk driver accident lawyers
Marti (Unverified)
I am just angry that this topic even has to be discussed. Take a look in the shelters...all pit bulls! Where are they coming from? Why are people from poor neighborhoods getting them and then dumping them in shelters? Why bother getting them at all. Everyone always tiptoes around and blames "cultural" differences. We all know thats the case. Find out who is breeding them in their backyards and selling them for $100 each to neighbors. Make them attend every euthansia of a pit bull in the shelters. Make them see what they have caused. I'd rather see them outlawed and die out than to suffer any more waiting for a loving home that will never come.
Czerny (Unverified)
I am devoted to pitbulls. They are intelligent, loving, obedient, eager to please, and clean. I have 3. In NYC, there are many pits and pit-mixes, and rarely do we hear of problems. We have off-leash areas in the parks and the pits play among other dogs, children, and seniors. The only time there's an incident is when the pit's owner is a jerk and uses his dog as a manhood extension by encouraging anti-social behavior and refusing to neuter.
Pit bull mom (Unverified)

Bullshit!I have owned and raised pit bulls all my life and I am 55 years of age.The problem is not the breed,but the ignorant people that purchase them for their own source of personal abuse.That would include crime,drugs,fighting and other criminal and unethical acts to satisfy their own personal agenda.This breed is smart and aims to please it's master.People need to be banned from adopting this pet unless they can prove they are worthy.Why don't we enthanize
the thugs and leave these pets alone.
Teresa in NC.

barbara Burghardt (Unverified)
If any dog gets the correct training, they will be a wonderful pet. It is the owners responsibilty to teach a dog right from wrong, the problem is that there are dog owners that are cruel to their pets, and that usually causes problems with their dogs!
Anonymous
I would be considered part of the younger crowd and I am totally against banning per breed. I have owned several pit bulls, all raised by me from the time they were weaned. When I brought my newborn son home, there was a 7 month old pit waiting for him. My son is now 14 and we buried the dog when he died from old age. There was never an incident of aggression from this dog towards my son or anyone else. On the flip side, our neighbor had a small dog that would try to attack my son every time he was out in the yard. The breed of the dog only determines how much force the dog has IF it should turn. The temperment of the dog is usually quite visible. Right now we have an Argentine Dogo, another dog gaining a fighting reputation, and she would rather lick you than bite you. She sleeps on my sons head or he uses her stomach for a pillow. Dogs do what they are taught to do or allowed to do (lack of training). We should not be banning or killing dogs simply because they happen to have strong jaws and powerful bodies. Police forces around the world love getting these dogs for their forces and train them well, why can't the rest of the world have that same ability?